Judith Miller Controversy

23 October 2005

It's Still Miller Time at the 'Times'

In case you wondered: The Judy Miller Saga is front page news in Italy, too. On my second day there last week, I managed to spot coverage not only in the International Herald Tribune but also in the Italian papers. Maybe, like many in the American press, the Italians resent her for helping to push their country into a war. But now, the scandal has gotten even more interesting, and disturbing, with...

More
23 October 2005

Times' Ombudsman Suggests Review of Miller

NEW YORK (AP) - The New York Times' ombudsman said the newspaper should review reporter Judith Miller's journalism practices to address "clear issues of trust and credibility" in her role in the CIA leak investigation. Miller's attorney called the newspaper's recent criticism of her "shameless." Times Public Editor Byron Calame also said the paper should consider updating its ethics guidelines on...

More
23 October 2005

NY Times reporter in CIA case criticized in paper

NEW YORK (Reuters) - A reporter for The New York Times came under sharp criticism in the pages of her own newspaper on Saturday, over her conduct related to a probe into the outing of a CIA operative. The Times' executive editor was quoted in the paper as saying reporter Judith Miller appeared to have misled it about her role in the controversy, and a top columnist suggested the Times' reputation...

More
23 October 2005

Newspapers dig for answers on their fate

In a recent e-mail chat about the future of their business, several young New York Times reporters concluded with dismay that most of their friends don't subscribe to the newspaper. At the San Jose Mercury News, hardened news hawks facing staff reductions have begun eyeing public relations jobs they once would have disdained. In Philadelphia, a news photographer who has "loved every minute" of his...

More
22 October 2005

How Miller was used by source

IN an extraordinary memo on the Judith Miller affair sent to the New York Times staff late Friday afternoon, the paper's executive editor, Bill Keller, did something far more important than admit errors and explain why they occurred. He took the focus of this lacerating incident off the Times' internal workings as a media institution and put it squarely where it belongs: on Miller, the individual...

More
22 October 2005

NY Times, reporter engage in public fight

WASHINGTON – In the latest fallout from the CIA leak investigation, reporter Judith Miller and The New York Times are engaging in a very public fight about her seeming lack of candor in the case. In a memo to the staff, Executive Editor Bill Keller says Miller "seems to have misled" the newspaper's Washington bureau chief, Phil Taubman, who said Miller told him in the fall of 2003 that she was not...

More
20 October 2005

Judith Miller, the Fourth Estate and the Warfare State

More than any other New York Times reporter, Judith Miller took the lead with stories claiming that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction. Now, a few years later, she's facing heightened scrutiny in the aftermath of a pair of articles that appeared in the Times on Oct. 16 -- a lengthy investigative piece about Miller plus her own first-person account of how she got entangled in the case of the Bush...

More
18 October 2005

Miller and the Times–accomplices in a war based on lies

The long-awaited "explanations"–one from the New York Times and another from the newspaper’s senior correspondent Judith Miller–about what led her to go to jail rather than testify before a federal grand jury, and then testify 85 days later, have raised more questions than answers. The Times’ page one news story and Miller’s "personal account" published Sunday portray behavior that has far more in...

More
18 October 2005

Newspaper's prestige punctured

Two years ago a scandal involving a rogue reporter called Jayson Blair plunged the New York Times into a crisis that triggered the removal of its editor, his deputy and a painful period of self-examination. Now the Times faces another scandal involving another favoured reporter and is enduring a similar bout of self-criticism. Some media critics and even Times staff members fear the fall-out could...

More
17 October 2005

Journalism community turns on Times, Miller

NEW YORK -- With a ferociousness usually reserved for presidents caught lying to the public, the journalism world has turned on The New York Times and its reporter Judith Miller, who only weeks ago was being lauded for going to jail to protect a source. A few media critics and academics suggested Monday that the Pulitzer Prize-winning reporter should be fired for her actions covering the search...

More