Judith Miller Controversy

2 December 2005

From watchdog to lap dog

It was a moment both remarkable and uncomfortable. There, on the night of November 21, was Bob Woodward looking nervous and dry-mouthed, trying to defend his hard-earned legacy to – of all people – a suddenly aggressive and sharp-elbowed Larry King. "So it’s quid pro quo," said the cable schmooze-meister to his old pal Woodward, snappily summing up the reporter’s symbiotic relationships with his...

More
29 November 2005

Why Woodward Is Still on the Hot Seat

Bob Woodward probably hoped that the long holiday weekend would break the momentum of an uproar that suddenly confronted him midway through November. But three days after Thanksgiving, on NBC's "Meet the Press," a question about the famed Washington Post reporter provoked anything but the customary adulation. "I think none of us can really understand Bob's silence for two years about his own role...

More
28 November 2005

Bob Woodward, High On Access, Thick With ?Senior Officials’

Early on in Plan of Attack, Bob Woodward’s surprisingly useful if analytically inane account of the inner machinations behind the Bush administration’s invasion of Iraq, Mr. Woodward supplies a little forensic digression on the White House, message discipline and the meaning of the phrase "senior administration officials." "A news story with that attribution," he wrote, "often carries a...

More
28 November 2005

The Man With the Inside Scoop

It was a cinematic image that lured thousands of young people into journalism, Robert Redford coaxing information out of Hal Holbrook in a dimly lit parking garage. And since, in real life, Bob Woodward fiercely protected Deep Throat's identity, what lingered was the mystique of a dogged journalist, plying his trade in the shadows. Three decades older and millions of dollars richer, Woodward still...

More
28 November 2005

The media's failure

If only Bob Woodward had used his inside sources for good instead of evil. Of course, he did just that in exposing the evils of the Nixon administration, but the revelation that the Washington Post journalist had concealed for 17 months the fact that a White House official had leaked former CIA agent Valerie Plame's identity to him has dulled the luster of this icon of investigative reporting...

More
28 November 2005

The Woodward Scandal Should Not Blow Over

Bob Woodward probably hoped that the long holiday weekend would break the momentum of an uproar that suddenly confronted him midway through November. But three days after Thanksgiving, on NBC’s "Meet the Press," a question about the famed Washington Post reporter provoked anything but the customary adulation. "I think none of us can really understand Bob’s silence for two years about his own role...

More
27 November 2005

More Questions for Bob Woodward

Most of the hundreds of readers who wrote and called after my column on Bob Woodward ran last week said I was way too soft on him and on The Post. I think their concerns and questions deserve to be answered. One of those readers, Bob Woodward, thinks that some of his critics have "pigeonholed" him unfairly. "For 34 years of reporting for The Post and 13 best-selling books, I have tried to focus on...

More
26 November 2005

Bob Woodward's blunders give journalism a black eye

Bob Woodward's recent actions bring a whole new meaning to the title, "All the President's Men." The veteran newsman for the Washington Post, who joined with Post reporter Carl Bernstein in investigating the Watergate coverup in the 1970s that brought down former President Richard Nixon, has gone from seeker of truth to concealer of truth. Woodward revealed last week he testified under oath to...

More
25 November 2005

Sometimes journalists and their sources get too cozy for comfort

The case against Scooter Libby is up in the air, but the case against the press is solid. Special counsel Patrick Fitzgerald indicted I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby Jr. on criminal charges, including obstruction of justice, making a false statement and perjury in the CIA leak investigation. The press indicted itself on grounds of coziness, self-interest and dishonesty. So far, Plamegate - the...

More
25 November 2005

The Fall of Bob Woodward

The recent revelations about the man often seen as the "moral hero" of the Watergate scandal, the Washington Post's Bob Woodward, have the feel of an interment ceremony. Reading press accounts of how Woodward swallowed the first Plame leak for a mere two-plus years without a peep and then went out on the Larry-King circuit to dismiss the significance of Plamegate, what came to mind was the burial...

More